Hicksville Sweet Shop
Hicksville, New York, USA
Discover Hicksville Sweet Shop in Hicksville, NY. Enjoy ice cream, cozy atmosphere, family-friendly dining, and great reviews. Check menu, hours, and location.
75 S Broadway #46, Hicksville, NY 11801, United States
Hicksville Sweet Shop
Hicksville, New York, USA
Overview
Hicksville Sweet Shop is a beloved ice cream shop nestled in Hicksville, NY, offering a cozy and casual atmosphere perfect for a quick, satisfying treat. Known for its homemade ice cream and classic diner-style menu, this spot delivers delightful options ranging from scrumptious sundaes and specialty ice cream flavors like Butter Pecan to savory wraps and cold salad platters.
With friendly service and affordable prices, the shop appeals to families and solo diners alike. Its wheelchair accessible entrance and parking accommodate all guests, while the cash-only policy keeps transactions simple. Located at 75 S Broadway #46, it stands out as a local favorite for casual dining and laid-back visits.
Gallery
Real shots of the food, atmosphere, and signature dishes at this location.
Local favorites
Hicksville Sweet Shop offers a cozy and casual setting with delicious ice cream and tasty breakfast options, making it a favorite stop for both families and solo diners.
With a 4.5 rating from over 130 reviews, this spot is praised for fresh, homemade food and friendly, speedy service.
Signature ice cream treats and rich coffee complement a menu featuring favorites like chocolate malt shakes and blueberry pancakes.
The welcoming, quiet atmosphere suits families and solo visitors alike, making it perfect for quick visits or relaxing meals.
Wheelchair accessible entrance and parking ensure all guests can enjoy the cozy environment without hassle.
Open early until 8 PM Monday through Saturday, allowing for breakfast, lunch, or afternoon treats throughout the week.
Enjoy classic menu items like the Western Omelet, French toast, and bacon cheeseburger in a nostalgic, casual setting.
Flexible dining options include dine-in with table service or quick takeout for those on the move.
Experience
Ideal for quick visits or a relaxed afternoon treat, Hicksville Sweet Shop fits well into both casual solo outings and family gatherings. The blend of ice cream specialties and hearty diner fare makes it versatile for various cravings and mealtime moments.
The welcoming ambiance combined with speedy table service creates a perfect setting to enjoy classic breakfast plates or indulge in handcrafted ice cream creations throughout the day. — FoodPlacee editorial note
Start the day with a hearty breakfast like the Western Omelet or Blueberry Pancakes paired with freshly brewed coffee.
Enjoy a cozy moment with quality coffee alongside a sweet sundae or scoop of Butter Pecan ice cream in a quiet setting.
Bring the whole family for kid-friendly dishes, served table-side, in a casual atmosphere where everyone feels welcome.
On the go? Grab takeout to enjoy classic ice cream treats or sandwiches made fresh, ideal for a fast yet satisfying meal.
Perfectly suited for solo visitors, offering easy seating and delicious bite-sized meals or sundaes to savor quietly.
Guest sentiment
A snapshot of what local diners frequently mention about this location.
"Wake up Hicksville!!! Young and old. Great food. Wonderful service. Good place for young to get a bite to eat without spending a fortune, hang out and enjoy company. Good place for older crowd to eat fresh food and share old stories! I can picture the olden days the place to meet up and enjoy a meal together. We need more of that! Highly recommend. Good people!! Chris"
"Great diner style type of place. I ordered the short stack with bacon. The pancakes were soft and moist, which allowed it to soak up the syrup. And the bacon was nice and crispy. And let me add that they do not skimp out on the bacon. I also ended up trying the corn beef hash which was good but not for me. The prices are very cheap compared to places in NY in spite of them raising up the prices. For 3 people we ended up paying around $33! A good hefty breakfast with coffee included! Where else can you find a cheap delicious breakfast?!"
"Blueberry pancakes are full of delicious blueberries. When they said small breakfast sausages I wasn't expecting 3. Yessssss! My husband loved his western omelette! 5 solid stars! Thanks for the referral Jimmy D!"
"A local hidden gem and quite simply one of my favorite eateries in Hicksville. You do not want to miss out on this place. Delicious!"
"A Hicksville classic! I've lived in Hicksville my entire life and have been here many many time. It's a nice a simple place that serves up good breakfast and lunch. Small menus keep quality and it's always quality when you come here. The other day I got the western omelet. Great size, great taste, made fresh and fast. The coffee is good and the waitress is always walking around freshening it up for you. You can't really beat the price and quality of the breakfast in the area. Great food, great people, great value."
"Classic old school luncheonette. Good food, good value, good service, good cup o’ joe. You come in here knowing what you want and knowing what your gonna get. It’s my first time back here in 27 years or so and I love that it’s virtually the same. I’ll definitely come back in a couple weeks."
"Amazing food and service the just recently remodeled the inside of the building. Lower prices then your traditional diner with less processed ingredients it has been owned by the two same people for a very long time and they make ice cream and chocolate from scratch they have amazing chocolate chip pancakes that they make with the chocolate that they make their. Also the place has amazing fried fish broiled fish something you wouldn't expect to find so good at a diner. Love hicksville sweet shop!!!!"
"Amazing cheeseburger and milkshake. The staff is so friendly and this place is cash only!"
Visit info
Weekly hours below — always confirm with the business before holidays or special events.
| Monday | 07:00 AM - 08:00 PM |
| Tuesday | 07:00 AM - 08:00 PM |
| Wednesday | 07:00 AM - 08:00 PM |
| Thursday | 07:00 AM - 08:00 PM |
| Friday | 07:00 AM - 08:00 PM |
| Saturday | 07:00 AM - 08:00 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Plan a visit during convenient morning or early evening hours to enjoy fresh meals and ice cream in a calm, family-friendly atmosphere.
On the map
Find your way to Hicksville Sweet Shop in New York .
Questions answered
Find answers to common questions about Hicksville Sweet Shop, an inviting ice cream shop in Hicksville, NY. Discover details on menu, hours, services, and more to plan your visit.
For owners
Update this page with accurate hours, menu details, photos, and business notes — and reach food lovers searching for places like yours on FoodPlacee.
Menus, prices, hours, services, and availability may change. Please contact the food place directly before visiting or ordering.